| School Name | Grades | Address | Zip | Phone | County | Type | District Name |
| Amsterdam School | n/a | 185 Amsterdam Rd
New Holland, PA | 17557 | | Lancaster | private | |
| Center Grove School | 1-8 | Rr 3 Box 408
New Holland, PA | 17557 | (717) 354-5696 | Lancaster | private | |
| Crossroads Mennonite School | 1-10 | 3030 Division Hwy
New Holland, PA | 17557 | (717) 354-7266 | Lancaster | private | |
| East Earl Amish Parochial School | n/a | P.O. Box 99
New Holland, PA | 17557 | | Lancaster | private | |
| Fairmount School | 1-8 | 104 Fairmount Rd
New Holland, PA | 17557 | | Lancaster | private | |
| Friendship Baptist Academy | n/a | 653 Meeting House Road
New Holland, PA | 17557 | (717) 355-2615 | Lancaster | private | |
| Garden Spot Middle School | 7-8 | 669 E Main St # 609
New Holland, PA | 17557 | (717) 354-1561 | Lancaster | public | Eastern Lancaster County School District |
| Garden Spot Senior High School | 9-12 | 669 E Main St
New Holland, PA | 17557 | (717) 354-1555 | Lancaster | public | Eastern Lancaster County School District |
| Greenbank School | 1-8 | Box 352
New Holland, PA | 17557 | (717) 354-7869 | Lancaster | private | |
| Greenbank School | 1-8 | 661 Ranck Road
New Holland, PA | 17557 | (717) 354-9151 | Lancaster | private | |
| Groffdale School | 1-8 | 179 Voganville Rd
New Holland, PA | 17557 | (717) 656-2250 | Lancaster | private | |
| Linden Grove School | 1-8 | 138 Linden Grove Rd
New Holland, PA | 17557 | (717) 542-4263 | Lancaster | private | |
| Meadow Creek Parochial School | 1-8 | 149 Meadowcreek Rd
New Holland, PA | 17557 | (717) 354-7142 | Lancaster | private | |
| Meeting House Rd School | 1-8 | 385 Sollenberger Rd
New Holland, PA | 17557 | (717) 355-2209 | Lancaster | private | |
| Mill Creek Valley Parochial School | 1-8 | 149 Meadowcreek Rd
New Holland, PA | 17557 | | Lancaster | private | |
| Mill Creek Valley Parochial School | n/a | 178 Meadowcreek Road
New Holland, PA | 17557 | | Lancaster | private | |
| New Holland Elementary School | K-6 | 126 Eastern School Rd
New Holland, PA | 17557 | (717) 354-1520 | Lancaster | public | Eastern Lancaster County School District |
| Pequea Mennonite School | 1-10 | 5025 Diem Rd
New Holland, PA | 17557 | (717) 354-7841 | Lancaster | private | |
| Red Well School | 1-7 | 436 Redwell Rd.
New Holland, PA | 17557 | (717) 354-4781 | Lancaster | private | |
| Red Well School | 1-8 | Peters Rd
New Holland, PA | 17557 | (717) 768-8135 | Lancaster | private | |
| Reidenbach Parochial School | 1-8 | 150 Snyder Dr
New Holland, PA | 17557 | (717) 440-4065 | Lancaster | private | |
| Summitview Christian School | 1-9 | 144 Summitville Rd
New Holland, PA | 17557 | (717) 354-3140 | Lancaster | private | |
| Walnut Hill Parochial School | 1-8 | 284 S Shirk Rd
New Holland, PA | 17557 | (717) 354-0607 | Lancaster | private | |
| Welsh Mountain Amish Parochial | 1-8 | 5310 Hammond Rd
New Holland, PA | 17557 | | Lancaster | private | |
| West Terre Hill School | n/a | Rd 1
New Holland, PA | 17557 | | Lancaster | private | |
| Wide Hollow School C/O John Ma | 1-8 | 741 Red Run Road
New Holland, PA | 17557 | | Lancaster | private | |
