2025 Compare Climate & Weather:
Carmel, IN vs Red Hook, NY

Change Cities

Highlights

On average, there are 167 sunny days per year in Red Hook. Carmel averages 185 sunny days per year. The US average is 205 sunny days.

Red Hook, New York gets 47 inches of rain, on average, per year. Carmel, Indiana gets 42.2 inches of rain, on average, per year. The US average is 38.1 inches of rain per year.

Red Hook averages 45.1 inches of snow per year. Carmel averages 22.9 inches of snow per year. The US average is 27.8 inches of snow per year.

Weather Highlights

Red Hook, New York
Summer High: the July high is around 84 degrees
Winter Low: the January low is 13
Rain: averages 47 inches of rain a year
Snow: averages 45.1 inches of snow a year

Carmel, Indiana
Summer High: the July high is around 84.3 degrees
Winter Low: the January low is 18.9
Rain: averages 42.2 inches of rain a year
Snow: averages 22.9 inches of snow a year

BestPlaces Comfort Index

Red Hook

The annual BestPlaces Comfort Index for Red Hook is 6.9 (10=best), which means it is about average compared to other places in New York.

6.9 / 10

August, July and June are the most pleasant months in Red Hook, while January and February are the least comfortable months.

Carmel

The annual BestPlaces Comfort Index for Carmel is 7.0 (10=best), which means it is about average compared to other places in Indiana.

7 / 10

September, June and August are the most pleasant months in Carmel, while January and December are the least comfortable months.

Average Monthly High / Low (°F)

Month	Carmel, IN	Red Hook, NY
January	34° / 19°	34° / 13°
February	39° / 22°	38° / 16°
March	50° / 30°	48° / 24°
April	62° / 41°	61° / 34°
May	72° / 51°	71° / 45°
June	81° / 61°	80° / 54°
July	84° / 64°	84° / 58°
August	83° / 62°	82° / 57°
September	77° / 54°	74° / 49°
October	65° / 43°	63° / 37°
November	52° / 34°	51° / 30°
December	38° / 23°	39° / 20°

Hot, Freezing, Rainy, Snowy Days: Carmel / Red Hook

Month	Hot Days	Freezing Days	Rainy Days	Snowy Days
January	0 / 0	27 / 30	11 / 10	6 / 5
February	0 / 0	23 / 26	9 / 8	4 / 4
March	0 / 0	18 / 25	11 / 10	2 / 2
April	0 / 0	6 / 12	12 / 11	0 / 0
May	0 / 1	0 / 3	13 / 12	0 / 0
June	2 / 2	0 / 0	11 / 11	0 / 0
July	5 / 5	0 / 0	11 / 10	0 / 0
August	4 / 3	0 / 0	8 / 10	0 / 0
September	1 / 0	0 / 1	8 / 9	0 / 0
October	0 / 0	4 / 10	9 / 10	0 / 0
November	0 / 0	14 / 19	10 / 10	1 / 1
December	0 / 0	25 / 28	12 / 10	5 / 3

July is the hottest month for Carmel with an average high temperature of 84.3°, which ranks it as about average compared to other places in Indiana. In Carmel, there are 5 comfortable months with high temperatures in the range of 70-85°. The most pleasant months of the year for Carmel are September, June and August.

July is the hottest month for Red Hook with an average high temperature of 84.0°, which ranks it as one of the hottest places in New York. In Red Hook, there are 5 comfortable months with high temperatures in the range of 70-85°. The most pleasant months of the year for Red Hook are June, September and August.

January has the coldest nighttime temperatures for Carmel with an average of 18.9°. This is warmer than most places in Indiana.

January has the coldest nighttime temperatures for Red Hook with an average of 13.0°. This is colder than most places in New York.

In Carmel, there are 11.6 days annually when the high temperature is over 90°, which is cooler than most places in Indiana.

In Red Hook, there are 11.2 days annually when the high temperature is over 90°, which is hotter than most places in New York.

In Carmel, there are 116.3 days annually when the nighttime low temperature falls below freezing, which is warmer than most places in Indiana.

In Red Hook, there are 153.2 days annually when the nighttime low temperature falls below freezing, which is colder than most places in New York.

In Carmel, there are 5.1 days annually when the nighttime low temperature falls below zero°, which is about average compared to other places in Indiana.

In Red Hook, there are 8.9 days annually when the nighttime low temperature falls below zero°, which is colder than most places in New York.

May is the wettest month in Carmel with 5.0 inches of rain, and the driest month is February with 2.3 inches. The wettest season is Summer with 29% of yearly precipitation and 19% occurs in Spring, which is the driest season. The annual rainfall of 42.2 inches in Carmel means that it is about average compared to other places in Indiana.

July is the wettest month in Red Hook with 4.6 inches of rain, and the driest month is February with 2.8 inches. The wettest season is Autumn with 27% of yearly precipitation and 22% occurs in Spring, which is the driest season. The annual rainfall of 47.0 inches in Red Hook means that it is wetter than most places in New York.

May is the rainiest month in Carmel with 12.5 days of rain, and August is the driest month with only 8.2 rainy days. There are 124.7 rainy days annually in Carmel, which is rainier than most places in Indiana. The rainiest season is Summer when it rains 28% of the time and the driest is Winter with only a 22% chance of a rainy day.

May is the rainiest month in Red Hook with 12.1 days of rain, and February is the driest month with only 7.9 rainy days. There are 122.0 rainy days annually in Red Hook, which is less rainy than most places in New York. The rainiest season is Summer when it rains 27% of the time and the driest is Spring with only a 23% chance of a rainy day.

An annual snowfall of 22.9 inches in Carmel means that it is snowier than most places in Indiana.

An annual snowfall of 45.1 inches in Red Hook means that it is about average compared to other places in New York.

January is the snowiest month in Carmel with 7.6 inches of snow, and 4 months of the year have significant snowfall.

February is the snowiest month in Red Hook with 14.6 inches of snow, and 6 months of the year have significant snowfall.

DID YOU KNOW?

Many people confuse Weather and Climate, but they are different. Weather refers to the conditions of the atmosphere over a short period of time, while Climate refers to the conditions of the atmosphere over a long period of time.

Weather, more specifically, refers to how the atmosphere behaves and its effects on life and human activities. Most people think of Weather in terms of what can be observed: temperature, humidity, precipitation, and cloudy/sunny conditions. Weather conditions constantly change on a minute-to-minute basis.

Climate is a record of the average weather conditions for a given place over a long period of time, often referred to as Climate Normals. A 30-year period of record is a common requirement to be considered a Climate Normal.

Reviews for Carmel 2 Reviews

Jill · Sherman Oaks, CA

re:

Over 16 years ago

Hi. I'd like to know if you still feel the same way about living in Broomfield. I went there this past July to check it out (along with Lafayette, Boulder (can't More

| Reply

NC For Me · Apex, NC

re:

Over 16 years ago

Apex is perfect for what you are looking for. It's close enough to Raleigh, Durham, Chapel Hill to find a job and Cary the next town over, is a little more expensive but More

| Reply

Start Your Review of Carmel

See all reviews

Reviews for Red Hook 2 Reviews

Jill · Sherman Oaks, CA

re:

Over 16 years ago

Hi. I'd like to know if you still feel the same way about living in Broomfield. I went there this past July to check it out (along with Lafayette, Boulder (can't More

| Reply

NC For Me · Apex, NC

re:

Over 16 years ago

Apex is perfect for what you are looking for. It's close enough to Raleigh, Durham, Chapel Hill to find a job and Cary the next town over, is a little more expensive but More

| Reply

Start Your Review of Red Hook

See all reviews

Compare Cost of Living

Compare Carmel Cost of Living vs Red Hook Cost of Living: Taxes, Childcare, Groceries, Health...

Compare now

Zips In Carmel, Indiana

46032, 46033, 46290

Zips In RED HOOK, NEW YORK

No Zip Codes Here.

Learn More About CARMEL, INDIANA

Overview
Cost of Living
Job Market
Crime
Climate
Economy
Religion
Voting

Learn More About Red Hook, New York

Overview
Cost of Living
Job Market
Crime
Climate
Economy
Religion
Voting

Premium Subscription

Includes Cost of Living compares for child care, utilities, transportation, health, taxes, housing for home owners vs renters, weather, insurance premiums and so much more.

Upgrade now

Compare City	Compared To This City
Portland, Oregon	Newport, Oregon	Compare
San Jose, California	Charlotte, North Carolina	Compare
Lakeville, Massachusetts	Portland, Oregon	Compare
Ephrata, Washington	Cedar Rapids, Iowa	Compare
Gulf Shores, Alabama	Gulfport, Mississippi	Compare
Tucson, Arizona	Calexico, California	Compare
Hood River, Oregon	Bainbridge Island, Washington	Compare
Indianapolis, Indiana	St. Joseph, Michigan	Compare
Normal, Illinois	Kansas City, Missouri	Compare
Jacksonville, Florida	Tallahassee, Florida	Compare

2025 Compare Climate & Weather:
Carmel, IN vs Red Hook, NY

Highlights

Weather Highlights

BestPlaces Comfort Index

Average Monthly High / Low (°F)

Hot, Freezing, Rainy, Snowy Days: Carmel / Red Hook

January has the coldest nighttime temperatures for Carmel with an average of 18.9°. This is warmer than most places in Indiana.

January has the coldest nighttime temperatures for Red Hook with an average of 13.0°. This is colder than most places in New York.

In Carmel, there are 11.6 days annually when the high temperature is over 90°, which is cooler than most places in Indiana.

In Red Hook, there are 11.2 days annually when the high temperature is over 90°, which is hotter than most places in New York.

In Carmel, there are 116.3 days annually when the nighttime low temperature falls below freezing, which is warmer than most places in Indiana.

In Red Hook, there are 153.2 days annually when the nighttime low temperature falls below freezing, which is colder than most places in New York.

In Carmel, there are 5.1 days annually when the nighttime low temperature falls below zero°, which is about average compared to other places in Indiana.

In Red Hook, there are 8.9 days annually when the nighttime low temperature falls below zero°, which is colder than most places in New York.

An annual snowfall of 22.9 inches in Carmel means that it is snowier than most places in Indiana.

An annual snowfall of 45.1 inches in Red Hook means that it is about average compared to other places in New York.

January is the snowiest month in Carmel with 7.6 inches of snow, and 4 months of the year have significant snowfall.

February is the snowiest month in Red Hook with 14.6 inches of snow, and 6 months of the year have significant snowfall.

DID YOU KNOW?

Reviews for Carmel 2 Reviews

Reviews for Red Hook 2 Reviews

Most Recent Searches On Compare Climate & Weather

Compare Cost of Living

Zips In Carmel, Indiana

Zips In RED HOOK, NEW YORK

Learn More About CARMEL, INDIANA

Learn More About Red Hook, New York

Premium Subscription

BestPlaces Tools

About BestPlaces

Follow Us

2025 Compare Climate & Weather:Carmel, IN vs Red Hook, NY

Highlights

Weather Highlights

BestPlaces Comfort Index

Average Monthly High / Low (°F)

Hot, Freezing, Rainy, Snowy Days: Carmel / Red Hook

January has the coldest nighttime temperatures for Carmel with an average of 18.9°. This is warmer than most places in Indiana.January has the coldest nighttime temperatures for Red Hook with an average of 13.0°. This is colder than most places in New York.

In Carmel, there are 11.6 days annually when the high temperature is over 90°, which is cooler than most places in Indiana.In Red Hook, there are 11.2 days annually when the high temperature is over 90°, which is hotter than most places in New York.

In Carmel, there are 116.3 days annually when the nighttime low temperature falls below freezing, which is warmer than most places in Indiana.In Red Hook, there are 153.2 days annually when the nighttime low temperature falls below freezing, which is colder than most places in New York.

In Carmel, there are 5.1 days annually when the nighttime low temperature falls below zero°, which is about average compared to other places in Indiana.In Red Hook, there are 8.9 days annually when the nighttime low temperature falls below zero°, which is colder than most places in New York.

An annual snowfall of 22.9 inches in Carmel means that it is snowier than most places in Indiana.An annual snowfall of 45.1 inches in Red Hook means that it is about average compared to other places in New York.

January is the snowiest month in Carmel with 7.6 inches of snow, and 4 months of the year have significant snowfall.February is the snowiest month in Red Hook with 14.6 inches of snow, and 6 months of the year have significant snowfall.

DID YOU KNOW?

Reviews for Carmel 2 Reviews

Reviews for Red Hook 2 Reviews

Most Recent Searches On Compare Climate & Weather

Compare Cost of Living

Zips In Carmel, Indiana

Zips In RED HOOK, NEW YORK

Learn More About CARMEL, INDIANA

Learn More About Red Hook, New York

Premium Subscription

BestPlaces Tools

About BestPlaces

Follow Us

2025 Compare Climate & Weather:
Carmel, IN vs Red Hook, NY

January has the coldest nighttime temperatures for Carmel with an average of 18.9°. This is warmer than most places in Indiana.

January has the coldest nighttime temperatures for Red Hook with an average of 13.0°. This is colder than most places in New York.

In Carmel, there are 11.6 days annually when the high temperature is over 90°, which is cooler than most places in Indiana.

In Red Hook, there are 11.2 days annually when the high temperature is over 90°, which is hotter than most places in New York.

In Carmel, there are 116.3 days annually when the nighttime low temperature falls below freezing, which is warmer than most places in Indiana.

In Red Hook, there are 153.2 days annually when the nighttime low temperature falls below freezing, which is colder than most places in New York.

In Carmel, there are 5.1 days annually when the nighttime low temperature falls below zero°, which is about average compared to other places in Indiana.

In Red Hook, there are 8.9 days annually when the nighttime low temperature falls below zero°, which is colder than most places in New York.

An annual snowfall of 22.9 inches in Carmel means that it is snowier than most places in Indiana.

An annual snowfall of 45.1 inches in Red Hook means that it is about average compared to other places in New York.

January is the snowiest month in Carmel with 7.6 inches of snow, and 4 months of the year have significant snowfall.

February is the snowiest month in Red Hook with 14.6 inches of snow, and 6 months of the year have significant snowfall.