2025 Compare Cities Overview:
Holtsville, NY vs Fire Island, NY

Are people in Fire Island older or younger than people in Holtsville?
- The Median Age in Fire Island is 8.8 years older than in Holtsville.

Are housing costs cheaper in Fire Island or Holtsville?
- Fire Island housing costs are 1.6% less expensive than Holtsville housing costs.

Which city has a longer commute, Fire Island or Holtsville?
- The average commute for residents of Fire Island is 7.0 minutes shorter than it is for residents of Holtsville.

Things to do in Holtsville?
Holtsville, NY is a pleasant village east of Centereach featuring several spectacular spots such as Blydenburgh County Park perfect for exploring or Splish Splash Waterpark ideal for recreational activities; locals gather yearly at the remarkable St. Anselms Holiday Fair celebrating local culture with music and art.

Things to do in Fire Island?
Living in Fire Island is a dream come true for many. This picturesque island, located off the coast of Long Island, offers plenty of activities to keep you entertained no matter what time of year it is. From beach days and swimming in the Atlantic Ocean to strolling along the boardwalk's shops and restaurants, there's something for everyone to enjoy. Whether you're looking for an adventurous day out or just want to relax on the sand, Fire Island has it all. The community is close-knit and welcoming, making it easy to feel right at home.