2026 Compare Cities Overview:
Montclair, NJ vs West Nyack, NY

Are people in West Nyack older or younger than people in Montclair?
- The Median Age in West Nyack is 11.1 years older than in Montclair.

Are housing costs cheaper in West Nyack or Montclair?
- West Nyack housing costs are 41.1% less expensive than Montclair housing costs.

Which city has a longer commute, West Nyack or Montclair?
- The average commute for residents of West Nyack is 8.1 minutes shorter than it is for residents of Montclair.

Things to do in Montclair?
Montclair, New Jersey is situated in Essex county providing visitors leisure areas such as Eagle Rock Reservation while also having employment opportunities at Mountainside Hospital along with entertainment opportunities at Wellmont Theatre.

Things to do in West Nyack?
Living in West Nyack, NY is a great experience. The town is full of friendly people, lush parks, and plenty of recreational activities to enjoy. From shopping at the Palisades Center Mall to hiking through Hook Mountain State Park, there's something for everyone to do here. The schools are highly rated and the local restaurants offer some of the best food around. West Nyack has a small-town feel with big city amenities just a short drive away in New York City. Whether you're looking for outdoor recreation or an urban retreat, this charming little village has it all!