2025 Compare Cities Cost of Living:
Old Tappan, NJ vs Garden City, NY

Change Cities
Highlights
Is it cheaper to live in Garden City or is it cheaper to live in Old Tappan?
- Garden City is 13.9% more expensive than Old Tappan.

Which city has more affordable housing, Garden City or Old Tappan?
- Garden City housing costs are 12.4% more expensive than Old Tappan housing costs.

Is Health Care more affordable in Old Tappan or is Health Care more affordable in Garden City.
- Health related expenses are 28.5% more in Garden City.
 Old Tappan, NJGarden City, NYUnited States
 Overall  Unlock160.6100
 Food & Groceries108.5  Unlock100
 Health  Unlock125.8100
 Housing284.4  Unlock100
 Median Home Cost  Unlock$986,000$338,100
 Utilities113  Unlock100
 Transportation  Unlock170.1100
 Miscellaneous140.9  Unlock100
100 = National Average (Below 100 means cheaper than the US average. Above 100 means more expensive.)
DID YOU KNOW?

In order to keep your same standard of living your salary can vary greatly - whether you buy or rent, require child care, or want to include taxes. This is why we are now offering a Premium Salary & Cost of Living Calculator.

Our Premium Calculator Includes:
- Compare Cities cost of living across 9 different categories
- Personal salary calculations can optionally include Home ownership or rental, Child care, and Taxes (with details on state and local sales, income, property and automobile taxes)
- Includes the cost of Child Care for toddlers or infants, at a day care center or home care
- Grocery prices, detailed for 29 staple items in six categories
- Difference in cost of Utilities, including electric, gas and fuel oil
- Health Care Premiums and hospital expenses for major surgeries
- Taxes, Fees and Expenses you should know about, such as local car insurance rates, automobile taxes and registration, commuting costs.
- and 100s of other items you should consider before you relocate

Upgrade to Premium | See Example

Reviews for Old Tappan    0 Reviews

Start Your Review of Old Tappan

Reviews for Garden City    2 Reviews

Over 16 years ago

Expensive, pretty, good commute to New York  More

   |    Reply

Over 18 years ago

Bus and railroad service is excellent. However, there is too much traffic. Travelling across town takes at least 15 minutes during off peak hours. Around noon and six  More

   |    Reply

Start Your Review of Garden City


Premium Subscription
Includes Cost of Living compares for child care, utilities, transportation, health, taxes, housing for home owners vs renters, weather, insurance premiums and so much more.


The premier source for comprehensive city data for over 30 years.

© Best Places. All rights reserved.