2025 Compare Cities Overview:
Shelter Island, NY vs Montauk, NY

Are people in Montauk older or younger than people in Shelter Island?
- The Median Age in Montauk is 0.5 years older than in Shelter Island.

Are housing costs cheaper in Montauk or Shelter Island?
- Montauk housing costs are 7.9% more expensive than Shelter Island housing costs.

Which city has a longer commute, Montauk or Shelter Island?
- The average commute for residents of Montauk is 9.5 minutes shorter than it is for residents of Shelter Island.

Things to do in Shelter Island?
Living in Shelter Island, NY can be a peaceful and unique experience. The island is relatively small compared to other parts of New York, but it still offers plenty of opportunities for exploration and recreation. There are many parks and beaches to visit, as well as shops and restaurants that offer delicious local fare. With its close proximity to both Long Island Sound and the Atlantic Ocean, there are also plenty of water-based activities available. From fishing charters to kayaking trips, one can find many ways to enjoy the beautiful waters surrounding Shelter Island. Additionally, living in Shelter Island gives you a chance to escape from the hustle and bustle of city life with its quiet atmosphere. For those who want a more relaxed lifestyle with the convenience of being close to the city, Shelter Island is definitely worth exploring.

Things to do in Montauk?
Living in Montauk, New York is a unique and rewarding experience. Located on the eastern tip of Long Island, Montauk offers stunning views of the Atlantic Ocean and is widely known as a surfing hotspot. Visitors can enjoy miles of beaches to explore, lighthouses to visit, and charming seaside towns to explore. With so much outdoor activity available, Montauk makes for an ideal summer getaway or year-round home. Those who call Montauk home take advantage of the area's laidback atmosphere and can enjoy world-class fishing, swimming, sailing and paddle boarding opportunities. With its picturesque landscapes and vibrant community spirit, Montauk is truly an unforgettable place to live.