2026 Compare Cities Overview:
St. Augustine Shores, FL vs Butler Beach, FL

Are people in Butler Beach older or younger than people in St. Augustine Shores?
- The Median Age in Butler Beach is 5.3 years older than in St. Augustine Shores.

Are housing costs cheaper in Butler Beach or St. Augustine Shores?
- Butler Beach housing costs are 56.1% more expensive than St. Augustine Shores housing costs.

Which city has a longer commute, Butler Beach or St. Augustine Shores?
- The average commute for residents of Butler Beach is 6.3 minutes longer than it is for residents of St. Augustine Shores.

Things to do in St. Augustine Shores?
St. Augustine Shores, FL is a charming coastal community located on the south side of St. Johns County. It offers beautiful waterfront views, and plenty of homes, as well as recreation centers, parks, and beaches to keep residents busy.

Things to do in Butler Beach?
Living in Butler Beach, FL is a truly unique experience. The town offers a serene, small-town feel with the added bonus of being within close proximity to larger cities like Jacksonville and St. Augustine. There are plenty of activities to enjoy in the area, including beautiful beaches and local parks that offer opportunities for fishing, swimming, or simply relaxing with a cool drink while enjoying the stunning views of the Atlantic ocean. Residents also have access to some great restaurants and shopping options along A1A. For those who love nature and want to be close to the beach without sacrificing convenience, Butler Beach is an ideal place to call home.