2025 Compare Cities Overview:
St. James, NY vs Oakdale, NY

Are people in Oakdale older or younger than people in St. James?
- The Median Age in Oakdale is 0.6 years older than in St. James.

Are housing costs cheaper in Oakdale or St. James?
- Oakdale housing costs are 6.2% less expensive than St. James housing costs.

Which city has a longer commute, Oakdale or St. James?
- The average commute for residents of Oakdale is 0.9 minutes shorter than it is for residents of St. James.

Things to do in St. James?
St. James, NY is an inviting village northeast of Smithtown full of amazing places to explore like Blydenburgh County Park presenting its distinctive landscape or Lakeland County Park great for outdoor activities; their annual event St James Day brings people together with food and games every June.

Things to do in Oakdale?
Oakdale, NY is a beautiful, vibrant town located in Suffolk County. The town offers a variety of activities for visitors and locals alike, from great restaurants and shopping to outdoor recreation. It is an excellent place to raise a family with its safe streets and community-focused schools. The people of Oakdale are friendly and welcoming to all who visit, making it a great place to live. There are plenty of jobs available throughout the area, providing economic stability. Oakdale has something for everyone – quiet residential neighborhoods, bustling downtown areas, scenic parks and trails, plus plenty of nearby attractions that make it an ideal location for those looking for a unique and vibrant community experience.