Our Premium Cost of Living Calculator includes House Prices for Homeowners and Renters, Home Appreciation, Rental Prices, Local Property Taxes and other must-know details. Upgrade to Premium

Housing
104.8% higher in Shelter Island, New York
than in Fire Island, New York

Fire Island, NY vs. Shelter Island, NY

Compared to Fire Island, Shelter Island is:

Housing (homeowner)

104.8% higher

Housing appreciation

Rent Comparison

	Fire Island, NY	Shelter Island, NY	Difference
Studio	$1,450	$1,750	20.7%
1 Bedroom	$1,800	$2,180	21.1%
2 Bedroom	$2,170	$2,610	20.3%
3 Bedroom	$2,780	$3,360	20.9%
4 Bedroom	$3,060	$3,690	20.6%

Customize Your Own Personal House Price & Taxes

Enter the price of your home in Fire Island, New York and we will give you a comparable home price and estimated taxes in Shelter Island, New York.

Fire Island, NY

Shelter Island, NY

Difference

Cost of Utilities

The premier source for comprehensive city data for over 30 years.

Current City	Comparison City
Boston, Massachusetts	Marshfield, Wisconsin	Compare
Palmdale, California	Manassas, Virginia	Compare
Washington, District of Columbia	Philadelphia, Pennsylvania	Compare
St. John, Indiana	Los Angeles, California	Compare
Pikesville, Maryland	Los Angeles, California	Compare
Sewickley township (Westmoreland County), Pennsylvania	Murfreesboro, Tennessee	Compare
Rowland Heights, California	Owensboro, Kentucky	Compare
Bristol, Tennessee	Spring Grove, Pennsylvania	Compare
Nashville, Tennessee	Elgin town, South Carolina	Compare
Aurora, Colorado	Irvine, California	Compare

Fire Island, New York vs. Shelter Island, New York

Housing Compare

Fire Island, NY vs. Shelter Island, NY

Housing appreciation

Rent Comparison

Customize Your Own Personal House Price & Taxes

Popular Cost of Living Searches

BestPlaces Tools

About BestPlaces

Follow Us