Fire Island, New York vs. Shelter Island, New York

Housing Compare

Our Premium Cost of Living Calculator includes House Prices for Homeowners and Renters, Home Appreciation, Rental Prices, Local Property Taxes and other must-know details. Upgrade to Premium

Housing
  104.8% higher in Shelter Island, New York
than in Fire Island, New York
Fire Island, NY vs. Shelter Island, NY
Compared to Fire Island, Shelter Island is:
  Housing (homeowner)
  104.8% higher
Housing appreciation
   Rent Comparison
Fire Island, NYShelter Island, NYDifference
Studio$1,450$1,750  20.7%
1 Bedroom$1,800$2,180  21.1%
2 Bedroom$2,170$2,610  20.3%
3 Bedroom$2,780$3,360  20.9%
4 Bedroom$3,060$3,690  20.6%
Customize Your Own Personal House Price & Taxes

Enter the price of your home in Fire Island, New York and we will give you a comparable home price and estimated taxes in Shelter Island, New York.

Fire Island, NY
Shelter Island, NY
Difference
Cost of Utilities

The premier source for comprehensive city data for over 30 years.

© Best Places. All rights reserved.