2025 Compare Cities Overview:
Commack, NY vs Carmel, NY

Are people in Carmel older or younger than people in Commack?
- The Median Age in Carmel is 0.3 years younger than in Commack.

Are housing costs cheaper in Carmel or Commack?
- Carmel housing costs are 21.3% less expensive than Commack housing costs.

Which city has a longer commute, Carmel or Commack?
- The average commute for residents of Carmel is 4.6 minutes longer than it is for residents of Commack.

Things to do in Commack?
Commack, New York is located in Suffolk County providing its citizens great recreational activities such as Sunken Meadow State Park plus stores like Walt Whitman Shops and dining spots near Bella’s Pizzeria.

Things to do in Carmel?
Carmel, NY is situated on the east shore of Putnam County and is known for its rolling hills and beautiful views of Lake Mahopac. The area provides many recreational opportunities including golfing, fishing and hiking.