Overview
Cost of Living
Crime
Climate
Interactive Map
Jobs
Education
Economy
Health
Religion
People
Politics & Voting
Housing Stats
Commute Time
Rankings
Upgrade to Premium

2025 Compare Cities Housing:
Fishers Island, NY vs Shelter Island, NY

Change Cities
Highlights
- The median age of a home in Fishers Island is 7.8% older than the median age of a home in Shelter Island.
 Fishers Island, NYShelter Island, NYUnited States
 Median Home Age51  Unlock42
 Median Home Cost  Unlock$1,458,000$338,100
 Home Appr. Last 12 months13.4%  Unlock16.6%
 Home Appr. Last 5 yrs.  Unlock61.7%57.0%
 Home Appr. Last 10 yrs.58.4%  Unlock101.1%
 Property Tax Rate  Unlock$22.7$11.0
 Homes Owned3.1%  Unlock57.4%
 Housing Vacant  Unlock51.7%11.2%
 Homes Rented2.6%  Unlock31.4%
 space
 Avg Rent For Home Or Apartment
 Fishers Island, NYShelter Island, NYUnited States
 Average Rent  Unlock$3,310$1,840
 Studio Apartment$1,470  Unlock$1,080
 1 Bedroom Home or Apartment  Unlock$2,180$1,180
 2 Bedroom Home or Apartment$2,200  Unlock$1,430
 3 Bedroom Home or Apartment  Unlock$3,360$1,860
 4 Bedroom Home or Apartment$3,110  Unlock$2,160
 space1
 Vacant Housing
 Fishers Island, NYShelter Island, NYUnited States
 Vacant For Rent  Unlock0.0%1.9%
 Vacant Rented0.0%  Unlock0.4%
 Vacant For Sale  Unlock1.4%0.7%
 Vacant Sold0.0%  Unlock0.4%
 Vacant Vacation  Unlock46.7%3.6%
 Vacant Other2.4%  Unlock4.1%
 space2
 Owner-Occupied Housing Value
 Fishers Island, NYShelter Island, NYUnited States
 Less Than $20,000  Unlock0.0%2.6%
 $20,000 to $39,9990.0%  Unlock2.4%
 $40,000 to $59,999  Unlock0.0%2.8%
 $60,000 to $79,9990.0%  Unlock3.9%
 $80,000 to $99,999  Unlock0.0%4.5%
 $100,000 to $149,9990.0%  Unlock11.3%
 $150,000 to $199,999  Unlock3.2%13.0%
 $200,000 to $299,9990.0%  Unlock20.1%
 $300,000 to $399,999  Unlock0.0%13.6%
 $400,000 to $499,9990.0%  Unlock8.3%
 $500,000 to $749,999  Unlock18.4%9.7%
 $750,000 to $999,9990.0%  Unlock3.9%
 $1,000,000 to $1,499,999  Unlock16.6%2.2%
 $1,500,000 to $1,999,99958.3%  Unlock0.8%
 $2,000,000 and over  Unlock5.5%1.1%
 space3
 Housing Units By Year Built
 Fishers Island, NYShelter Island, NYUnited States
 2015 and Newer0.0%  Unlock0.2%
 2010 to 2014  Unlock21.1%13.6%
 2000 to 20097.1%  Unlock13.6%
 1990 to 1999  Unlock7.6%13.6%
 1980 to 19895.2%  Unlock13.2%
 1970 to 1979  Unlock15.9%14.8%
 1960 to 196922.7%  Unlock13.6%
 1950 to 1959  Unlock9.2%10.0%
 1940 to 19490.8%  Unlock4.7%
 1939 or Earlier  Unlock23.2%12.2%
Transportation
Reviews for Fishers Island    0 Reviews

Start Your Review of Fishers Island

Reviews for Shelter Island    0 Reviews

Start Your Review of Shelter Island

Most Recent Searches On Compare Cities
Moving from:Moving to:
 Kansas City, MissouriNew Milford, New JerseyCompare
 Telluride, ColoradoGlencoe, IllinoisCompare
 Woodward, OklahomaMooreland, OklahomaCompare
 Sandwich, MassachusettsWhite Springs, FloridaCompare
 Shoreline, WashingtonVashon, WashingtonCompare
 Sandwich, MassachusettsWhite Springs, FloridaCompare
 Hermitage, PennsylvaniaYork, PennsylvaniaCompare
 Blacksburg, South CarolinaGainesville, FloridaCompare
 Georgetown, MassachusettsIrvine, CaliforniaCompare
 Fredericksburg, TexasCarson, CaliforniaCompare

Learn More About Fishers Island, New York
Overview
Cost of Living
Job Market
Crime
Climate
Economy
Religion
Voting
Learn More About Shelter Island, New York
Overview
Cost of Living
Job Market
Crime
Climate
Economy
Religion
Voting
Premium Subscription
Includes Cost of Living compares for child care, utilities, transportation, health, taxes, housing for home owners vs renters, weather, insurance premiums and so much more.


The premier source for comprehensive city data for over 30 years.

Privacy Policy  •  Terms of Use  •  Returns & Refunds
© Best Places. All rights reserved.