2025 Compare Cities Overview:
Fishers Island, NY vs Shelter Island, NY

Are people in Shelter Island older or younger than people in Fishers Island?
- The Median Age in Shelter Island is 14.0 years older than in Fishers Island.

Are housing costs cheaper in Shelter Island or Fishers Island?
- Shelter Island housing costs are 183.2% more expensive than Fishers Island housing costs.

Which city has a longer commute, Shelter Island or Fishers Island?
- The average commute for residents of Shelter Island is 0.0 minutes shorter than it is for residents of Fishers Island.

Things to do in Fishers Island?
Living in Fishers Island, NY is a unique experience. The island itself is small, with a population of only around 250 people, but it bristles with life and activity. With beautiful beaches along the coast and plenty of outdoor activities to be enjoyed at any time of year, the island offers its inhabitants a peaceful, relaxed lifestyle that is perfect for those who want to get away from the hustle and bustle of everyday life. Throughout the summer months there are numerous festivals and events that bring people together and provide an opportunity to meet other like-minded islanders and share stories. In addition to all this, Fishers Island also has some of the best seafood restaurants in New England tucked away in its charming harbor. All in all, Fishers Island makes for a wonderful place to live!

Things to do in Shelter Island?
Living in Shelter Island, NY can be a peaceful and unique experience. The island is relatively small compared to other parts of New York, but it still offers plenty of opportunities for exploration and recreation. There are many parks and beaches to visit, as well as shops and restaurants that offer delicious local fare. With its close proximity to both Long Island Sound and the Atlantic Ocean, there are also plenty of water-based activities available. From fishing charters to kayaking trips, one can find many ways to enjoy the beautiful waters surrounding Shelter Island. Additionally, living in Shelter Island gives you a chance to escape from the hustle and bustle of city life with its quiet atmosphere. For those who want a more relaxed lifestyle with the convenience of being close to the city, Shelter Island is definitely worth exploring.