2025 Compare Cities Overview:
Grand Island, NE vs Carthage, SD

Are people in Carthage older or younger than people in Grand Island?
- The Median Age in Carthage is 1.6 years older than in Grand Island.

Are housing costs cheaper in Carthage or Grand Island?
- Carthage housing costs are 54.8% less expensive than Grand Island housing costs.

Which city has a longer commute, Carthage or Grand Island?
- The average commute for residents of Carthage is 4.9 minutes longer than it is for residents of Grand Island.

Things to do in Grand Island?
Grand Island, NE is a charming city situated in the heart of Nebraska’s farm country. This picturesque landscape provides plenty of recreational opportunities and scenic vistas throughout the year. Grand Island also offers excellent educational facilities and luxurious shopping centers at its doorstep.

Things to do in Carthage?
Living in Carthage, South Dakota is a truly unique experience. The small town of about 500 people is nestled in between the Missouri River and the James River, making for stunningly beautiful views. The people are friendly and welcoming, but there’s never a dull moment as there’s always something going on in town. The main industry here is farming, with plenty of opportunities to get involved with local agriculture and livestock production. With the nearby lakes, rivers, and rolling hills, the area offers plenty of outdoor activities such as camping, hiking, boating, fishing, and even hunting. Carthage has a variety of restaurants and shops to explore as well, giving visitors an understanding of what small-town living looks like. All in all it’s a great place to visit or live!