2025 Compare Cities Overview:
Holtsville, NY vs Bay Shore, NY

Change Cities
Highlights
Are people in Bay Shore older or younger than people in Holtsville?
- The Median Age in Bay Shore is 3.7 years younger than in Holtsville.

Are housing costs cheaper in Bay Shore or Holtsville?
- Bay Shore housing costs are 14.2% less expensive than Holtsville housing costs.

Which city has a longer commute, Bay Shore or Holtsville?
- The average commute for residents of Bay Shore is 0.8 minutes longer than it is for residents of Holtsville.

Things to do in Holtsville?
Holtsville, NY is a pleasant village east of Centereach featuring several spectacular spots such as Blydenburgh County Park perfect for exploring or Splish Splash Waterpark ideal for recreational activities; locals gather yearly at the remarkable St. Anselms Holiday Fair celebrating local culture with music and art.

Things to do in Bay Shore?
Bay Shore NY lies southwest Babylon renowned mainly for its wealth of cultural attractions ranging from art galleries to wineries giving vacationers a chance explore area's culture while still having easy access stunning beaches along Long Island’s coast!

 Holtsville, NYBay Shore, NYUnited States
 Population  Unlock31,488329,725,481
 Median Income$118,883  Unlock$69,021
 Median Age  Unlock35.638.4
 Avg. Home Price$519,900  Unlock$338,100
 Unemployment Rate  Unlock6.1%6.0%
 Avg. Commute Time33.04  Unlock26.38
Reviews for Holtsville    0 Reviews

Start Your Review of Holtsville

Reviews for Bay Shore    6 Reviews

Over 11 years ago

Long Island is very expensive. Bay Shore is definitely one of the cheaper parts of the island, but it's still  More

   |    Reply

Over 13 years ago

Great community but saddled with taxes that are detracting from the quality of life here on Long  More

   |    Reply

I find the quality of life here in Bay Shore becoming more and more difficult. Due to the lack of convenient public transportation our population is forced to clog the  More

   |    Reply

Start Your Review of Bay Shore


Premium Subscription
Includes Cost of Living compares for child care, utilities, transportation, health, taxes, housing for home owners vs renters, weather, insurance premiums and so much more.


The premier source for comprehensive city data for over 30 years.

© Best Places. All rights reserved.