2025 Compare Cities Overview:
Middle Island, NY vs Elkhart, IN

Change Cities
Highlights
Are people in Elkhart older or younger than people in Middle Island?
- The Median Age in Elkhart is 10.4 years younger than in Middle Island.

Are housing costs cheaper in Elkhart or Middle Island?
- Elkhart housing costs are 54.1% less expensive than Middle Island housing costs.

Which city has a longer commute, Elkhart or Middle Island?
- The average commute for residents of Elkhart is 15.3 minutes shorter than it is for residents of Middle Island.

Things to do in Middle Island?
Middle Island, NY is a hamlet located in the Town of Brookhaven on Long Island. Situated between Queens and the Hamptons, Middle Island offers a unique blend of suburban living, as well as easy access to New York City. Residents can enjoy the many parks and recreation areas, as well as numerous shopping and dining opportunities. With its small-town feel, rich history, vibrant culture, and beautiful surroundings, Middle Island is an ideal place to call home.

Things to do in Elkhart?
Elkhart, Indiana is a historic city located in the northern part of the state. Home to Elkhart River and numerous lakes and parks, Elkhart is a haven for outdoor activities like fishing, boating, hiking and camping. Visitors can also explore Elkhart’s vibrant culture with its many museums, theaters and art galleries. From shopping on Main Street to exploring the historic downtown district or strolling along an scenic bike path, Elkhart has something for everyone! With its friendly people and welcoming atmosphere, Elkhart is a great place to visit no matter what season you choose.

 Middle Island, NYElkhart, INUnited States
 Population  Unlock53,838329,725,481
 Median Income$81,599  Unlock$69,021
 Median Age  Unlock3438.4
 Avg. Home Price$398,800  Unlock$338,100
 Unemployment Rate  Unlock4.8%6.0%
 Avg. Commute Time34.53  Unlock26.38
Reviews for Middle Island    2 Reviews

Over 19 years ago

I have lived in Suffolk County all of my life with the exception of 4 years in the Marines. It is basically a decent place. The problem is the school taxes, property  More

   |    Reply

Middle Village, Queens is surrounded by a large park called Juniper Valley  More

   |    Reply

Start Your Review of Middle Island

Reviews for Elkhart    8 Reviews

Over 12 years ago

I grew up in Elkhart and it's not the greatest city. My car had been broken into numerous times while living in northern Indiana (South Bend as well). I attribute to  More

   |    Reply

Over 13 years ago

I moved away from Elkhart and returned 20 years later. During my time away I lived in many locations around the west coast - but mostly in Arizona. The last couple of  More

   |    Reply

Over 13 years ago

I left Elkhart 20 years ago, lived mainly in Arizona and returned recently. I have been pleasantly surprised at the wonderful people I've met here. I've made more  More

   |    Reply

Start Your Review of Elkhart


Premium Subscription
Includes Cost of Living compares for child care, utilities, transportation, health, taxes, housing for home owners vs renters, weather, insurance premiums and so much more.


The premier source for comprehensive city data for over 30 years.

© Best Places. All rights reserved.