2025 Compare Cities Overview:
Staten Island, NY vs Smithtown, NY

Change Cities
Highlights
Are people in Smithtown older or younger than people in Staten Island?
- The Median Age in Smithtown is 4.8 years older than in Staten Island.

Are housing costs cheaper in Smithtown or Staten Island?
- Smithtown housing costs are 36.5% more expensive than Staten Island housing costs.

Which city has a longer commute, Smithtown or Staten Island?
- The average commute for residents of Smithtown is 10.5 minutes shorter than it is for residents of Staten Island.

Things to do in Staten Island?
Staten Island, New York is a borough of New York City that offers its residents amazing landscapes, entertainment and culture. From beach strolls to hikes on the greenbelts, outdoor lovers can find plenty of activities on the island. Art enthusiasts will find creativity and inspiration at the St. George Theatre or at several museums in the area. Staten Island has something for everyone - amusement parks, zoos, sports complexes and beaches are just a few reasons to visit this vibrant borough.

Things to do in Smithtown?
Smithtown, New York is a charming and historic town located on the North Shore of Long Island. Visitors can enjoy a variety of cultural attractions such as galleries, museums, music venues, and seasonal festivals. There are also plenty of outdoor activities including golf courses and hiking trails. In addition to its many attractions, Smithtown boasts beautiful beaches that are perfect for relaxing in the sun. With its close proximity to both Manhattan and many other popular tourist destinations, Smithtown is an ideal destination for anyone looking for a memorable getaway!

 Staten Island, NYSmithtown, NYUnited States
 Population  Unlock116,560329,725,481
 Median Income$89,427  Unlock$69,021
 Median Age  Unlock45.238.4
 Avg. Home Price$660,600  Unlock$338,100
 Unemployment Rate  Unlock6.1%6.0%
 Avg. Commute Time44.05  Unlock26.38
Reviews for Staten Island    2 Reviews

Expensive housing. Lots of traffic at times, but still many times nicer than the rest of NYC. Staten Island has a few beautiful beaches, and overall most of the people  More

   |    Reply

Over 7 years ago

Low quality of life, expect a 60-90 minute commute if you live here as there are no jobs on the island. As for the people, they are very rude and miserable, have serious  More

   |    Reply

Start Your Review of Staten Island

Reviews for Smithtown    0 Reviews

Start Your Review of Smithtown


Premium Subscription
Includes Cost of Living compares for child care, utilities, transportation, health, taxes, housing for home owners vs renters, weather, insurance premiums and so much more.


The premier source for comprehensive city data for over 30 years.

© Best Places. All rights reserved.