Review of Chicago, Illinois


Calm down - take a chill pill
Star Rating - 12/30/2017
Chicago is a world class city with economic and political challenges like nearly every other part of the United States. If you can get your mind to accept that reality, then maybe you can move on to embracing the cultural and historical impact this city has had and continues to have on the world. Universities with Nobel prizes, architechectural leadership, ethnic diversity, musical and theatrical excellence, numerous athletic accomplishments, world class cuisine, and many other things to get excited about. All of this wrapped in a neighbor friendly, humble, midwestern environment.

Some other comments.

Weather: The legend of the Chicago winter is far worse than the reality. Yes the entirety of the Midwest has some tough winter days, but Chicago is far from being America’s Siberia. The sun shines 54% of the time in Chicago, which is consistent with most major cities (typical range is bewtween 50-60% for cities outside of the Southwestern US). The average January low in Chicago is 19, the US average is 23. I’m going to be wearing winter clothes for either those temps. Wind - maybe the greatest Chicago Urban Myth. Chicago is the 75th windiest city in the US, the Chicago average wind speed is slightly above the US average. In fact, in many years the most uncomfortable days in Chicago are hot, humid days in July and August. On the other side of the coin, late summer and early autumn is typically spectacular in Chicago.

Crime: One of the most consistently stated pieces of disinformation in the US is the perceived upward trend of violent crime, at the national level violent crime has been steadily dropping for 3 to 4 decades. Having said this, murder rates in many major cities continue to be disturbingly high, including Chicago. However, while the gross numbers for Chicago are high (Chicago is a highly populated city), on a per capita basis Chicago is not even in the top ten for murder rate in the US. Much of the violent crime is concentrated in a few neighborhoods and every Chicago area person knows where they are.

Hypothesis: When the national media is reporting on crime, nasty weather, etc. they often in Chicago. When people are traveling, attending conferences, etc they are often going through O’Hare or in Chicago. The effect is to anchor a bias in people about Chicago, and then when you experience that one cold blustery day in Chicago or hear that one upsetting crime story, your biases are now artificially confirmed.

Is Chicago perfect? Certainly not, but when I think about Chicago in comparison to some of the other cities I have read referrals to on this review page, Milwaukee, Detroit/Ann Arbor, Clearwater, I’m happy to continue to say Chicago is doing fine.
Jeffrey | Burr Ridge, IL
Reply to this Comment

3 Replies


Your post says you live in Burr Ridge..which is a FAR burb of Chicago..totally different lifestyle then those of us that live in the city. I have to agree with many here. The city and state are broke. The weather is poor (cold winters,humid summers) it has political, racial and corruption issues. Housing is reasonable but there are a lot of taxes..ie: bottled water 5cents per bottle, a bag fee , tax on prescriptions, etc etc. Yes it is a beautiful city if you sre only in the tourist areas. Yes to great museums and theres always something to do..a great place to visit but not a grest place to live
Janet | Chicago, IL | Report Abuse

Janet makes a great point. Burr Ridge is not Chicago it’s an upscale western suburb. Suburban living & city living are not similar. She sums it up fairly. She commented on my post too. I posted about my hatred for Chicago & she responded with a fair reply mostly disagreeing with me. So Janet deserves credit for being pretty objective in her comments on Chicago. Overall I disagree with Jeffrey. Yes crime is concentrated in certain areas but when I lived there a couple was walking in upscale Bucktown and they had their head bashed in with a baseball bat during a mugging. Also a tourist was “sodemized with a tree branch” by a homeless man at 6am in Grant Park the city’s front yard. I’m pretty sure Jeffrey wasn’t implying Bucktown was one of those bad neighborhoods.
Eric | Aurora, CO | Report Abuse

I had forgotten I posted this and I was just editing my bookmarks, found this post and the comments. Couple of points - yes now I live in Burr Ridge, but I have lived in Chicago earlier in my life, I have kids who live in the city, I do business in the city, I frequently do social things in the city, and I have in general been a Chicago area person for most of my life. I should note that I have also lived in other Midwestern, Northeastern, and Southeastern cities in the US, and I have traveled extensively throughout the world - so I do think I have a relevant viewpoint/opinion on how Chicago fits into the national and global spectrum. I think the replies our consistent with my hypothesis that people are taking specific experiences and/or anecdotal stories and leveraging them to confirm their biases. Doesn't every city have a story about a specific, individual violent act? Doesn't every city have tax and regulatory policies that doesn't make everyone happy? Doesn't every city have societal issues that could be better? Is the Midwestern weather in Chicago really worse than in any other Midwestern city? The one topic where I do have significant concerns for Chicago and the State of Illinois is political corruption. Now lets be clear, political corruption can be found in any society in the world. However, I do find the issues in Chicago and Illinois to be concerning - but its not clear to me that it has that much effect on the average person. I would argue, if you care and are concerned about political corruption, find a way to do something about it. Because if Chicago were to fail, that is not just a crisis for Chicago and Illinois, but that is a national and global crisis. Chicago is not Detroit, it is not a one industry town.
Jeffrey | Burr Ridge, IL | Report Abuse
MORE REVIEWS OF CHICAGO, ILLINOIS
- 1/14/2024
Beautiful city with reasonable cost of living
I've lived in Chicago city and later moved to suburbs when family size increased. Absolut...
Sam | Chicago, IL | No Replies

- 8/14/2023
My Favorite City in the Country
Chicago is probably the best value in a major city that you can find and my personal favor...
Daniel | Bremen, IN | No Replies

- 2/16/2023
Crime ridden Medical center.
I've live on north side and south side, UIC medical center. Don't move here go to the nort...
Betty | Chicago, IL | No Replies

- 11/15/2022
Good and Bad
A fun city to live in with great food! Housing isn't terrible compared to other big cities...
David | Chattanooga, TN | No Replies

- 8/17/2022
Capital of the Midwest, Just Dont Buy a House
I've spent my time between Chicago and Atlanta and in the end I chose to buy a home in Atl...
Bruce | Evanston, IL | No Replies

- 4/16/2022
Underrated
This place is so underrated. I just want to thank all the people leaving as you are making...
no | Mesa, AZ | No Replies