Bay Shore, NY Reviews


6 Reviews



Download our custom City Report to see exclusive
data on cost of living, crime, climate, and more.

Bay Shore, NY is a great place to visit for those who are looking for a more laid-back vacation destination. This charming Long Island village offers a variety of activities and attractions that make it a great place to visit. From boating and fishing on the Great South Bay to kayaking and paddleboarding along its inviting shoreline, there’s plenty of outdoor opportunity here. If you’re looking for more urban pursuits, Bay Shore features shop-lined streets, unique restaurants, and live entertainment venues. Those who have visited often comment on the friendly locals and how easy it is to feel at home in this city. The reviews of Bay Shore are overwhelmingly positive as visitors enjoy its relaxed atmosphere and convenient location near other popular destinations.

 based on 6 Reviews
Get to know Bay Shore with the latest comments and reviews from people who live in or have visited Bay Shore

Long Island is expensive - 2/26/2014
Long Island is very expensive. Bay Shore is definitely one of the cheaper parts of the island, but it's still Read More

Start Your Review of Bay Shore


Property Taxes Too High - 6/9/2012
Great community but saddled with taxes that are detracting from the quality of life here on Long Read More

Bay Shore - Long Island NY - 7/9/2008
I find the quality of life here in Bay Shore becoming more and more difficult. Due to the lack of convenient public transportation our population is forced to clog the roads and highways to get anywhere. The cost of gasoline gets higher each day and everything else is climbing right along with it. Home heating fuel has gone through the roof! On the bright side, we do have some of the finest beaches in the world even though the season is too short. And the close proximity to the city gives great opportunities for theater, museums, etc. The taxes here are prohibitive especially for the young folks starting out and for seniors living on fixed incomes. I am looking for "greener more affordable Read More

Close to the Ocean. - 2/27/2008
In the town of Bay Shore, you are minutes away from Robert Moses Beach and about an hour from Manhattan; as long as you don't hit any traffic. You can always take a train into the Big Apple as well. There is also a port to Fire Island, where several ferries await to take passengers back and Read More

the cost of living is a little higher than posted - 5/13/2006
It seems to me that the cost of living is a little higher than Read More

Bring your money and know the area well! - 4/11/2006
I have lived in Bay Shore on and off in my 40 years. I only came back here because of family and needing a place to stay when my husband, son and I returned from out of the area.
Long Island was once the dream place of every resident of New York City. Now it's dirty, overcrowded, and really horrible. There are good points about Long Island but you must have money, and I mean A LOT of money to do well here and enjoy life.
Houses here range on average about $300,000 or more (plus high, high taxes) for nothing special. There are hardly any legal apartments. In fact, illegal apartments on Long Island are discouraged but many people have them in their homes to help pay the enormous mortgages.
BayShore has a mixed culture which has gone from mostly White people (still in some parts of the town) to many more African Americans and a large Latino community.
In parts of Bay Shore crime is terrible. If you move here, stay away from Downtown at Read More

Overview
Compare Bay Shore, NY
cost of living
Compare food, housing, utilities, and more in Bay Shore, New York to any other city in the US.