Carlisle, PA Reviews


12 Reviews



Download our custom City Report to see exclusive
data on cost of living, crime, climate, and more.
Thanks for Voting!
What BestPlaces Users Say about Carlisle

Carlisle, Pennsylvania is a small town located in Cumberland County, known for its scenic countryside, historic charm, and strong community values. With a population of around 20,000 people, it offers a slower pace of life compared to big cities, making it an attractive place to live for many. However, like any place, there are pros and cons to living in Carlisle. To get a better understanding of what it's like to live in this town, I have included and summarized several user reviews from BestPlaces.net.

According to Jane, who has lived in Carlisle for 10 years, the town has "a great sense of community and a strong focus on education." She also mentions the convenience of having "all the necessary amenities within a short drive." However, she does caution that it can get "boring at times, especially for young adults looking for more entertainment options."

On the other hand, John, who relocated to Carlisle for work, has a different perspective. He describes it as a "quaint and charming town with beautiful surroundings," but notes that the job market is "limited" and "the cost of living is higher than expected." He also mentions that the winters can be "harsh and long."

Samantha, a long-time resident, appreciates the town's "rich history and charming downtown area," but points out that the traffic can get "quite bad during rush hour." She also mentions that the summers can be "extremely hot and humid," which may not be ideal for everyone.

Lastly, Mark, who recently moved to Carlisle for retirement, shares that "the cost of living and taxes are reasonable" and "the people are friendly and welcoming." However, he does mention that "the healthcare options are somewhat limited."

Overall, it seems that while Carlisle has its strengths such as community spirit, education, and charm, there are also some drawbacks to consider, such as limited job opportunities and potential weather challenges. It's important to weigh these factors and determine what is important to you when considering living in this particular place.

 based on 12 Reviews
Get to know Carlisle with the latest comments and reviews from people who live in or have visited Carlisle

From my experience. - 3/7/2015
It's not All bad but people here seem to be more prejudiced against minorities like me. Even more so than people in the South where i used to live.  Read More

Start Your Review of Carlisle


Carlisle - a nice place to live - 1/2/2015
Carlisle, PA, is at a crossroads of interstate 81 and US 76 (turnpike) which means its easy to get to, and easy to get out to places from. The town of Carlisle itself hosts Dickinson College, and The US Army War College, a huge Amazon distribution center, Carlisle Events (enormous car shows), and a lively downtown. The local schools are solid, and there's quite a bit of recreational events nearby - Hershey, hiking, hunting, trout fishing, theatre, and local athletic clubs. Read More

Welcome to PA, now empty out your pockets - 9/5/2012
We are still suffering from sticker shock after living here for 7 years. This state charges you for EVERYTHING and the ROI is near to nothing. You have to pay a toll just to enter PA from OH and NJ state lines. There are toll roads across the state that essentially doubles the cost of gas. Gas is cheaper by as much as $.50 in MD and VA. PA adds extra taxes to the gas. You have to pay toll charges for all local calls – usually about $.15 per minute. The taxes are very high. Residents must pay Federal, state, local, and ‘right to work’ taxes. They are all calculated on your gross income. We never see a return. There are so many township and bureaus, but the system is broken. Sidewalks, streets, and infrastructure are falling apart. Sadly this is true across the U.S. Home prices are unbelievably high and the homes are old or run down. Wages are not comparable for the cost of living. The perfect example of the way PA manages its finances is the capital Harrisburg. It is on the verge of Read More

Cultural desert for the arts... - 4/3/2009
Carlisle, PA is a very pretty, historic town of just under 20,000 people not far from Harrisburg, and only an hour and half from Washington, DC, Baltimore and the outskirts of Philadelphia. It is the home of Dickinson College, and near to Gettysburg. It boasts a cineplex which runs the usual American blockbusters, but there is not art movie house. There are a few small musical organizations, but no professional theater. While Dickinson College events are open to the public, they are poorly advertised to the general public. The only the Central Pennsylvania Youth Ballet offers peformances at a relatively professional level, and its company performs at the Whitaker Center in Harrisburg.There is a Blockbuster and a small video store. There are almost no good restaurants, by cosmopolitan standards: the gastronomical offerings go from coffee shop fare, and pizza parlor cuisine, to the standard chains like Abblebee's, Red Robin, Friendly's and Cracker Barrel and descending down Read More

Carlisle PA Quality of life - 5/31/2008
Carlisle is a great place to raise a family. The schools are good, crime's under control, the area is historic. Residents are very active in the community, creating many opportunities for family activities like sports, music, theatre, etc. The cost of living is good (below national average). Cities like Philadelphia, Baltimore, Washington and New York are all within day trip driving distance. The greater PA capital area provides many avenues for employment.

The negatives here are air quality (not good for asthma and allergies), and trucks. Carlisle is a trucking hub for much of the Eastern seaboard. Interstates here are packed with trucks, making travel somewhat harrowing. Trucking is an economic boon here, but most of us notice the Read More

Carlisle PA - 11/11/2007
I am originally from Northern California, so I am still getting used to the relatively high population density here in the East. However, Carlisle is a good place to raise children. What crime there is can be avoided by not being in certain parts of the town after dark. It is relatively close to the Washington DC area and to Philadelphia. The Harrisburg airport could be better, but good deals can be had. Schools are considered fairly good, and excellent shopping can be done within an hour's drive of the city. The town itself has numerous older homes with character, but housing prices are fairly high. All in all, it has been a good experience, but at some point I will probably head back West for the grand vistas (the local "mountains" are significantly lower than "mountains" in the West) and sense of Read More

Don't Go! - 7/26/2007
I have visited family there a few times and I would really rather not go back. It is definitely not somewhere I would want to move, it was bad enough that I had to get married out there. Carlisle is the reason I never want to move to a small town. They are really behind as far as technology, not many businesses even have websites! Huge religious town not that there is anything wrong with that but most are Pentecostal. There are plenty of Assemblies of God churches. I even attended a church service and yes witnessed the "speaking in tongues" very strange! Great place to live if you believe women are only here ( on Earth) so that men don't get bored! Yes, I know. They also believe you should be barefoot, pregnant, and do all the cooking, cleaning, shopping, and raising the children on their own. Not for me! Don't Read More

Employment - 6/21/2007
My Wife and I are planning to move to Carlisle or the Carlisle area as soon as I can find a job. Anyone in the area with any suggestions for a job service or something of that nature would be greatly appreciated. We currently live in Florida (past 3 years) but are from southwestern New York State. I have worked in the facilities maintenance field for 26 years including as a supervisor.
We will probably rent until we find a house so any info on those two aspects would also be helpful.
Something along the lines of work at a school, college, municipality, large hotel or housing develpment is probably the best fit for my skills.
Thanks for any info. Read More

Carlisle PA? - 5/14/2007
My husband may be transferring to Carlisle, after 4 years of Hot Southern Living in Texas - I am looking forward to being back in PA.

But I've never been to Carlisle. Tell me about the town, what's good, what's bad -

Since we are coming from an area that has become predominately Hispanic (Texas 65% Hispanic), we are curious as to the demographics of Carlisle.
Read More

Life after Hawaii - 10/14/2006
I love it here. I will always miss Hawaii, but there is life outside of the Islands. Being a native of Hawaii, born on Oahu, I thought I would never leave. I never wanted to, but the cost of living proved to much for me and my family. Alas I had to do what was best for my family. I now own a Home, a HUGE house, 2800 SqFt 6 beedroom 3.5 bath 2 car garage a nice lot with a huge storage shed and the property includes a rental unit that I own. This would cost my over a million dollars back home in Hawaii. Yes, yes I know it's not Hawaii, but I can always go back to visit. Besides, i would rather pay a $1200 dollar mortagage than one in excess of $2500 -$3000 a month!! I live 2 miles from work and I dont have to deal with Hawaii's horrid traffic, it's worse than the friggin Read More

Overview
Compare Carlisle, PA
cost of living
Compare food, housing, utilities, and more in Carlisle, Pennsylvania to any other city in the US.