2025 Compare Cities Rankings:
Arcata, CA vs Fredericksburg, VA

#1 Best Cities for Teleworking - Extra Large Metro Areas

#1 Most Secure Large Cities in the U.S.

#2 Healthiest Cities

#2 Most Difficult Cities to Navigate

#3 Most Irritation Prone Cities

#3 America's Riskiest Online Cities

#4 The Most (and Least) Gender Imbalanced Cities

#4 Best Cities After Military Service

#4 Best Airports to Make a Connection

#5 Sleep in the City Study

#5 Most Secure Places to Live 2011 (Large Metros)

#5 2005 High Gas Prices

#6 America’s Least Manly Cities

#7 Cities on the Edge of Greatness

#7 Failure To Lunch

#7 Wrinkle Ranking Cities Most at Risk for Skin Damage by 2040

#7 Best States for LGBTQ Rights

#9 Most Secure Places to Live in the U.S. (Large Metro Areas)

#9 Second Annual “America’s Manliest Cities” Rankings

#9 America's Most Playful Cities

#11 Sperlings Skincare Wrinkle Ranking

#12 Most and Least Risky Places for Identity Theft

#14 The Most Single Cities

#15 Most Competitive Private Colleges

#18 Drought-Riskiest Cities

#18 Best and Worst Cities for Sleep

#19 Most Competitive Public Colleges

#20 Best Cities for Board Gamers

#20 Gloomiest Places in America

#22 Most Popular Cities for the Holidays

#23 Best US Cities for Seniors 2011

#25 Best Cities for Seniors 2005

#26 Fiscally Fit Cities Report

#26 2005 Best Places to Live

#26 Sleepless Cities 2011

#29 High Gas Prices - Which Cities are Hit the Hardest?

#29 Most Romantic Cities for Boomers

#31 America's Best and Worst Cities for Crime (Large Metro Areas)

#34 America’s Manliest Sports Cities

#36 Best Baseball Cities

#38 Hypertension Hot Spots

#39 Worst Cities for Respiratory Infections

#40 Best Block Party Places

#42 Americas Manliest Cites 2011

#44 Stressful Cities 2012

#45 America’s Manliest Cities

#45 Most Comfortable Summer Cities

#46 America’s Best (and Worst) Cities for Dating

#50 Most Energetic Cities

#75 America's Migraine Hot Spots

#83 America's Most (and Least) Stressful Cities (100 Largest Metro Areas)

#87 Best Green Cities

Pros: Nature hikes Cons: One of highest crime rates in the nation. Opioid epidemic going on (you’ll regularly witness drug deals and ppl doing drugs) No  More

It takes a special set of preferences to select Arcata. Is this you? - You love clouds and fog. You are happy if you see the sun maybe 10-20 times a year. - Chilly  More

I've lived in Humboldt for over 30 yrs and know all the areas well. Arcata is the jewel of Humboldt due to having a university and many liberal creative people. There is  More

Fredericksburg has an undeniably small town charm and an all around appeal that is hard to beat, in the context of its proximity to the larger DC Metro area. The  More

I have lived in Fredericksburg for over 10 years and love it. The housing prices are affordable and this historic city has so much to offer. Ideal location also situated  More

Disclaimer right off the top; yes I know there are good people everywhere and some are here as well but Fredericksburg is far from an ideal place to live and here is  More