2025 Compare Cities Overview:
Fire Island, NY vs Sarasota, FL

Change Cities
Highlights
Are people in Sarasota older or younger than people in Fire Island?
- The Median Age in Sarasota is 0.9 years older than in Fire Island.

Are housing costs cheaper in Sarasota or Fire Island?
- Sarasota housing costs are 11.3% less expensive than Fire Island housing costs.

Which city has a longer commute, Sarasota or Fire Island?
- The average commute for residents of Sarasota is 5.7 minutes shorter than it is for residents of Fire Island.

Things to do in Fire Island?
Living in Fire Island is a dream come true for many. This picturesque island, located off the coast of Long Island, offers plenty of activities to keep you entertained no matter what time of year it is. From beach days and swimming in the Atlantic Ocean to strolling along the boardwalk's shops and restaurants, there's something for everyone to enjoy. Whether you're looking for an adventurous day out or just want to relax on the sand, Fire Island has it all. The community is close-knit and welcoming, making it easy to feel right at home.

Things to do in Sarasota?
Sarasota, Florida is a vibrant and inviting city located on the west coast of the Sunshine State. With its beautiful beaches and palm trees, Sarasota offers plenty of opportunities to relax and soak up some sun. Visitors can explore the area's unique culture with a visit to one of its many local attractions, while outdoor enthusiasts can enjoy a hike or bike ride through one of the many trails or parks around town. Plus, with its convenient location close to major cities like Tampa and St. Petersburg, visitors have easy access for a day trip if desired. With so much to offer, it's no wonder why Sarasota remains a popular destination year-round!

 Fire Island, NYSarasota, FLUnited States
 Population  Unlock53,786329,725,481
 Median Income$96,250  Unlock$69,021
 Median Age  Unlock4938.4
 Avg. Home Price$511,800  Unlock$338,100
 Unemployment Rate  Unlock4.6%6.0%
 Avg. Commute Time26.09  Unlock26.38
Reviews for Fire Island    0 Reviews

Start Your Review of Fire Island

Reviews for Sarasota    105 Reviews

Sarasota is my home from birth but those of us who have lived here long enough to have seen the devolution of what was once an easy to navigate, clean, low crime beach  More

   |    Reply

Starting to love Sarasota: Wife and I moved to Osprey- a small suburb between Sarasota and Venice. We're about 13 miles to downtown Sarasota, so not "city dwellers".   More

   |    Reply

As always, anyone considering moving to anyplace new, including Sarasota, needs to come down and spend a month or two before actually moving here. The city is overrun  More

   |    Reply

Start Your Review of Sarasota


Premium Subscription
Includes Cost of Living compares for child care, utilities, transportation, health, taxes, housing for home owners vs renters, weather, insurance premiums and so much more.


The premier source for comprehensive city data for over 30 years.

© Best Places. All rights reserved.