I grew up in a big city in TX, and have lived in Iowa, Missouri, spent time in Montana, Oregon, CA, and road-tripped all over the US. I moved to MA ~20 years ago, living in Allston initially (a college town & suburb of Boston), and remember the feeling my first year here. Sick - I felt sickened by the unfriendly, unpleasant, rude, angry, repressed drudges that seemed to be all around. It was culture shock. I'd never seen such unfriendliness elsewhere in the US. If I even made eye contact with someone passing on the street, they gave me a wide berth or took it as a threat, a challenge, "what are you looking at?!".
Heaven forbid I actually *smiled* at anyone. That's an indication you're a crazy person. Even if you're just having a good day, smiling to yourself, people look at you like something's wrong. (Recognize, in TX where I grew up, you didn't just make eye contact as you pass a fellow human being, you also frequently give them a polite nod or a "howdy" - given they're the only person you're likely to walk past for miles. Yes, really!
The only people who were friendly or animated came from India, China, other countries or regions where kindness, openness, and personality aren't quite as repressed or frowned upon. When I've talked w/natives of MA about why the culture here is so socially conservative they've chalked it up to Puritan roots. It simply isn't proper to be too cheerful, to express who you are for fear someone will be put off by your lack of reserve. The dress is reserved, socially conservative just like the people. Personal style might block you from getting/keeping that job you want. Someone with colorful hair, cheerful attire, or anything visibly playful about them gets the stink-eye. They must be nuts, or just extremely immature. This is not the time or place to be yourself. How to survive - limit yourself to just one piece of color or personal expression each day. (People will still comment "I wish I could get away with that look.")
Why do I stay? I moved here for work, and that has been something there is no shortage of in the Boston area. People take work very seriously, and you will work as hard as a New Yorker here. You quickly learn to adopt a neutral expression, avoid eye contact, and STOP ASKING people why the place is so glum. They don't understand the question. There is little diversity here, and most of the native New England white population has almost no experience with the rest of the US. Expensive international trips to major metropolitan cities aside, this is all they know. It is Normal. If people elsewhere in the country seem friendly, happy - the assumption is they are FAKE, disingenuous, and they probably have an angle or want something from you.
That's rubbish, but you'll never convince a dyed-in-the-wool native that a smile comes free, or might simply be *polite* acknowledgement. :)
Logically speaking, the population density here makes it virtually impossible to acknowledge individuals in the mass of people you pass each day in the city. I can understand why a smile stands out. But a single smile from one stranger has the power to lift the mood a little. That's a secret that hasn't made it to this part of the country.
You do learn coping mechanisms for dealing with the gloomy nature of the place. It isn't where I'd want to be forever, since the mood can be so emotionally draining. However, one positive is that New Englanders will help each other in moments of crisis. If your car goes off a snowy road, someone will be kind enough to stop and haul you out. Neighbors push other neighbors' cars out of icy ditches, and if a tree comes down in the street, residents up and down the road bearing chainsaws will break it up and clear the path. The stoic self-sufficiency of the region includes looking out for each other, and winter emergencies bring everyone together. It's about the only time you say hi to your neighbors or have a sense of community & contact with your fellow Man, however thin the interaction.
I have trouble believing the Brits are this reserved, unless they're very upper crust. I also can't blame the weather here for all of this gloom and doom (I mean, look at Finland's happiness quotient!). If you can find work elsewhere, I don't recommend NE to transplants from other parts of the country. However, each one of us living here might bring a little brightness to the area. For me, a smile has come to mean "you're not from around here, are you?"
Janet |
Cheshire, MA |
Report Abuse