2025 Compare Cities Rankings:
St. James City, FL vs Marco Island, FL

#1 Most Popular Cities for the Holidays

#8 Best Cities for Teleworking - Small Metro Areas

#20 Drought-Riskiest Cities

#45 America's Migraine Hot Spots

#58 2005 High Gas Prices

#61 America's Best and Worst Cities for Crime (Mid-Size Metro Areas)

#67 High Gas Prices - Which Cities are Hit the Hardest?

#97 Most Comfortable Summer Cities

#105 Best Green Cities

#220 2005 Best Places to Live

#3 Hurricane Hotspots

#37 America's Best and Worst Cities for Crime (Mid-Size Metro Areas)

#53 2005 Best Places to Live

#88 Best Green Cities

This town is so laid back that you could walk in reverse and still find nothing to do. Fishing, boating, bike riding on the 12 mile bike path, visinting the service  More

We just purchased a home here from San Diego, Ca. Marco island is so refreshing! It is Clean, no trash, people care about their yards and community with impeccable  More

We moved here upon retirement and have been delighted with our new community. With canals crisscrossing the entire island, most homesites are on the water, and we enjoy  More

I have been coming to Marco Island for the past couple of years to spend the 4th of July with my family in this beautiful city, but never again. From what we learned  More